Taking members with us on the digital journey
Our client had an ambition to create a digital-first communication experience for members.
Digital offered an opportunity to communicate more quickly, create a more connected member experience and reduce ongoing print and postage costs, freeing up budget to support members in other ways.
However, before the client could overhaul their communication materials, they wanted to give their members the opportunity to understand what the change meant, choose how they receive information from their Scheme, and feel confident getting online.
Our mission:
Take members on the journey towards digital communications, while giving them a clear choice about how they wanted to hear from their Scheme.
Help members feel more comfortable getting online by breaking down the barriers to logging in and making use of the administrator’s online portal.
Establish a clear picture of members’ communication preferences and agree the communication strategy for any non-responders, ensuring they continue to receive pension communications and that the cost / value remained appropriate for the Schemes.
Use the move to digital as an opportunity to encourage wider engagement with members’ pensions.
The challenge
The client was responsible for two Schemes, both of which were starting from different places. One scheme (Scheme A) had been through the e-disclosure exercise already and were more familiar with digital communications, and the other (Scheme B) hadn’t. Members in that group were more familiar with printed communications, had stated this preference through a recent member survey, and had generally varying levels of digital confidence and accessibility needs. This meant a one-size-fits-all approach wasn’t going to work.
Despite this, due to the scale of the membership, the Trustee felt it important to begin the move towards digital communications, to provide a future-proofed experience and cut down the scheme’s print costs – using that investment to support members in other ways.
We followed a four-step process, a warm-up followed by the required three-strike process, to ensure members were properly informed and supported throughout, rather than treating e-disclosure just as a compliance exercise.
The process included tailored messaging for each Scheme, recognising their different starting points and previous experience of e-disclosure.
The process included:
A warm-up that was designed to inform members of the move to digital and get them prepared by registering for their online member portal – this saw a sudden spike in registrations on the admin portal suggesting an early appetite for digital communication.
A big-bang “Take 5” campaign which saw members receive a printed folder containing a letter from the Trustee, tea and coffee, an online membership card, messaging to help members get comfortable logging in, plus an opportunity for members to choose their preferences. The pack was deliberately designed to stand out from a typical pension mailing and make the move to digital feel more personal and approachable.
A summer newsletter, shared as an example of the type of communication that would move online and what members would potentially miss out on, plus another nudge for members to make their choice.
A final reminder letter, giving members one last opportunity to tell us how they want to hear from their Scheme. For Scheme B, this was supported by a video guide showing them how to get online and use the administrator’s portal.
The exercise successfully resulted in…
Digital engagement
71% of Scheme A members and 44% of Scheme B members have opted into digital communications.
Preference for print
4% of Scheme A members and 9% of Scheme B members prefer printed communications.
No response
25% of Scheme A members and 47% of Scheme B members didn’t respond.
Importantly, the campaign also gave members a reason to take a closer look at their pension more widely, with increased activity around updating contact details, expression of wishes and bank details – a positive sign that the conversation around digital was encouraging broader pension engagement too.
Following the campaign, we worked closely with the Trustee to agree how the scheme should communicate with non-responders, ensuring that those who hadn’t made a choice weren’t simply left behind. It was agreed that outside of statutory communications, this would be dealt with on a case-by-case basis.
The financial update was delivered to non-responders as a printed postcard which nudged members to the website to access the full report. This offered an early opportunity to gauge member engagement versus value to the scheme, and we plan to continue to work with the Trustee to monitor its effectiveness allowing us to refine our approach.
Encouragingly, the number of non-responders has continued to fall since the campaign, reducing by 15.6% for Scheme A and 5.8% for Scheme B, as ongoing communications continue to give members opportunities to engage.